Tank vs. Tankless: Which Water Heater is Right for You?

Rachel Cherem

Written By Rachel Cherem

Published 02/15/24
Tank vs. Tankless: Which Water Heater is Right for You?

A reliable and efficient water heater ensures a steady supply of hot water for various household needs. As technology evolves, homeowners are faced with the dilemma of choosing between traditional tank water heaters and their more contemporary tankless counterparts. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the intricacies of tank and tankless water heaters to help you decide which one suits your needs best.

The Best Home Warranty Service

There's a reason Liberty Home Guard was rated the #1 Home Warranty
Service by U.S. News and World Report for 2021, 2022, and 2023. Check out our services.

Learn More

Understanding Tank Water Heaters

How Tank Water Heaters Work

Tank water heaters, also known as storage water heaters, have been a staple in households for decades. The basic principle behind their operation is simple: a large tank, typically made of steel or glass-lined steel, is filled with water. This water is then heated by a gas burner or an electric element located at the bottom of the tank. As the water heats up, it rises to the top of the tank, ready to be distributed through the hot water taps when needed.

Pros of Tank Water Heaters

1. Cost-Effective Installation

One of the main advantages of tank water heaters is their affordability both in terms of the unit itself and the installation costs. Traditional tanks are widely available and can be installed without significant modifications to your home's infrastructure.

2. Simplicity and Reliability

Tank water heaters are renowned for their simplicity. With fewer components and straightforward technology, they are less prone to malfunctions and are relatively easy to repair. This simplicity often translates into increased reliability and a longer lifespan.

3. Familiarity and Ubiquity

Being the more traditional option, tank water heaters are familiar to homeowners and contractors alike. This familiarity can be advantageous when it comes to repairs, maintenance, and replacement, as finding qualified professionals and replacement parts is typically easier.

4. Wide Range of Sizes

Tank water heaters come in various sizes to accommodate different household needs. Whether you have a small apartment or a large family home, there's a tank size suitable for your hot water requirements.

5. Adequate for Moderate Demand

While tank water heaters may have limitations in terms of standby heat loss and hot water supply, they are perfectly adequate for moderate hot water demands. A tank water heater may be a sensible choice for smaller households or those with less frequent simultaneous hot water use.

6. Reliability in Power Outages

In the event of a power outage, traditional tank water heaters can still provide hot water, especially if they run on gas. This can be a crucial factor for homeowners in areas prone to electricity disruptions.

Cons of Tank Water Heaters

1. Limited Energy Efficiency

One of the primary drawbacks of tank water heaters is their energy inefficiency. These units continuously heat and reheat the water in the tank, leading to standby heat loss. This constant energy consumption, even when hot water is not in use, can contribute to higher energy bills.

2. Limited Hot Water Supply

The size of the tank determines the amount of hot water available. Once the tank is depleted, it takes time to heat a new batch of water. This limitation can be a significant inconvenience, especially for larger households with high hot water demands.

3. Bulky Design

Tank water heaters take up space, and their bulky design may pose challenges when it comes to installation in tight or unconventional spaces. Homeowners with limited utility space might find tankless options more appealing.

4. Shorter Lifespan

Compared to tankless water heaters, traditional tanks generally have a shorter lifespan. The constant heating and cooling of water contribute to wear and tear, potentially leading to more frequent replacements.

5. Standby Heat Loss

Standby heat loss, a common occurrence in tank water heaters, means that the unit must continuously use energy to keep the stored water at the desired temperature. This constant energy consumption can be a significant factor in the overall operational cost.

6. Maintenance Requirements

Tank water heaters often require regular maintenance, including flushing to remove sediment buildup. Ignoring maintenance needs can lead to reduced efficiency and a shorter lifespan for the unit.

Exploring Tankless Water Heaters

How Tankless Water Heaters Work

Tankless water heaters, also known as on-demand water heaters, represent a modern and energy-efficient alternative to traditional tanks. Unlike their tank counterparts, tankless heaters do not store hot water. Instead, they heat water instantaneously as it flows through the unit.

Pros of Tankless Water Heaters

1. Energy Efficiency

One of the standout features of tankless water heaters is their energy efficiency. By only heating water when needed, these units eliminate standby heat loss, resulting in lower energy consumption and reduced utility bills.

2. Unlimited Hot Water Supply

Since tankless water heaters heat water on demand, there is no limit to the hot water supply. This is particularly beneficial for larger households with simultaneous hot water needs in multiple areas.

3. Space-Saving Design

Tankless water heaters are compact and can be installed in various locations, including closets and utility rooms. Their space-saving design is advantageous for homeowners with limited space or those looking to maximize usable square footage.

4. Longer Lifespan

Tankless water heaters generally have a longer lifespan compared to traditional tanks. With proper maintenance, these units can last up to 20 years or more, providing long-term reliability and cost-effectiveness.

5. Smart Technology Integration

Many tankless water heaters come equipped with smart technology, allowing homeowners to control and monitor their hot water usage through mobile apps. This integration adds a layer of convenience and energy management.

6. Reduced Environmental Impact

The energy efficiency of tankless water heaters not only translates to cost savings but also contributes to a reduced environmental impact. By minimizing energy consumption, these units help lower carbon footprints and promote sustainability.

7. Precise Temperature Control

Tankless water heaters offer precise temperature control, allowing users to set their preferred water temperature with greater accuracy. This can enhance comfort and prevent scalding or discomfort due to water that is too hot or too cold.

Cons of Tankless Water Heaters

1. Initial Cost

The upfront cost of tankless water heaters is higher than that of traditional tank water heaters. The unit itself is more expensive, and the installation may require modifications to your home's gas or electric system, adding to the overall cost.

2. Complex Installation and Maintenance

Installation of tankless water heaters can be more complex than that of tank units, requiring professional expertise. Additionally, regular maintenance is crucial to ensure optimal performance, and this may involve flushing the unit to prevent mineral buildup.

3. Limited Output for Simultaneous Use

While tankless water heaters offer unlimited hot water, their output is not limitless. In homes with multiple hot water demands simultaneously, such as running the dishwasher and taking a shower at the same time, there may be a decrease in water pressure or temperature.

4. Potential Cold-Water Sandwich Effect

Some users may experience what is known as a "cold-water sandwich" effect with tankless water heaters. This occurs when there is a brief burst of cold water between periods of hot water usage, which can be uncomfortable for some individuals.

5. Dependency on Flow Rate

The performance of tankless water heaters is heavily dependent on the flow rate of incoming water. Homes with low-flow fixtures or inconsistent water pressure may experience challenges in achieving the desired temperature.

6. Need for Ventilation

Gas-powered tankless water heaters require proper ventilation to ensure safe operation. This may involve additional installation considerations and costs.

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

Factors to Consider

1. Hot Water Demand

Consider your household's hot water demand. Tankless water heaters are ideal for homes with high demands, providing a continuous supply of hot water. On the other hand, tank water heaters may suffice for smaller households with lower hot water needs.

2. Initial Budget

Evaluate your budget for the initial investment and installation. While tank water heaters are more budget-friendly initially, tankless units offer long-term energy savings that may offset the higher upfront costs.

3. Available Space

Examine the available space in your home. Tankless water heaters are compact and can be installed in various locations, while tank units require dedicated space for the storage tank.

4. Future Considerations

Think about your long-term plans for your home. If energy efficiency and long-term savings are a priority, investing in a tankless water heater may align with your future goals.

5. Technology Preferences

Consider your comfort with technology. Tankless water heaters often come with advanced features and smart technology integration. If you appreciate the convenience of controlling your water heater through a mobile app, a tankless unit might be the right fit.

6. Climate Considerations

Take into account your local climate. In colder regions, the standby heat loss from tank water heaters may be less significant, and the higher initial cost of tankless units may be less justifiable. Conversely, in warmer climates, the energy efficiency of tankless heaters becomes more appealing.

The Best Home Warranty Service

There's a reason Liberty Home Guard was rated the #1 Home Warranty
Service by U.S. News and World Report for 2021, 2022, and 2023. Check out our services.

Learn More

Get Started With
Liberty Home Guard

Check out our top rated plans and policies.

Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958
Special Offer
Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958