Duplicate Coverage in Home Warranty

Liberty Home GuardGlossary

When homeowners invest in a home warranty, they often seek comprehensive protection for their valuable assets. However, understanding the intricacies of coverage can sometimes be challenging. One concept that homeowners should be aware of is "duplicate coverage." In this blog post, we will delve into the world of home warranties and explore what duplicate coverage entails, why it matters, and how homeowners can navigate this aspect to make informed decisions.

Home warranties provide homeowners with a sense of security by offering coverage for repairs and replacements of major systems and appliances. Unlike homeowners insurance, which primarily covers damage caused by perils such as fire, theft, or natural disasters, home warranties focus on the wear and tear that occurs over time due to regular use.

Protect What's Most Important With
America's #1 Home Warranty

Get A Free Quote
  • Comprehensive Plans
  • Highly Competitive Rates
  • 24/7/365 Claims
  • Online Portal

What is Duplicate Coverage in a Home Warranty

Duplicate coverage in the context of a home warranty refers to a situation where the same item or aspect of your home is covered by more than one insurance policy or warranty. This redundancy can lead to confusion, inefficiencies, and potential financial waste. Understanding duplicate coverage is crucial for homeowners to make informed decisions about their protection plans and avoid unnecessary expenses.

To put it simply, if you have multiple insurance policies or warranties that provide the same coverage for a specific item, system, or appliance in your home, you have duplicate coverage. This means that if a repair or replacement is needed, you might be tempted to file claims with both providers, resulting in confusion and delays in the claims process.

Types of Duplicate Coverage in Home Warranty

Duplicate coverage in the realm of home warranties can manifest in various ways, leading to potential confusion, inefficiency, and increased costs for homeowners. Understanding the types of duplicate coverage is essential for making informed decisions and avoiding unnecessary expenses. Here are the key types of duplicate coverage to be aware of:

1. Insurance Overlap:

Homeowners' insurance policies and home warranties may both provide coverage for certain damages or losses, resulting in overlapping protection. While homeowners insurance typically covers structural damage and personal property loss caused by specific perils, home warranties focus on the wear and tear that occurs over time due to regular use.

For instance, consider a scenario where a burst pipe causes water damage to your home. Your homeowner's insurance might cover the water damage caused by the burst pipe, while your home warranty includes coverage for plumbing system repairs. This creates an overlap in coverage for the water damage, potentially leading to confusion about which policy to file a claim with.

2. Manufacturer's Warranty Overlap:

Appliances in your home often come with manufacturer warranties that cover defects or malfunctions within a specific period. However, some home warranty plans also include coverage for these appliances, creating a potential redundancy in protection.

Imagine you have a refrigerator that comes with a manufacturer's warranty covering repairs for a year. Additionally, your home warranty plan provides coverage for all major appliances, including refrigerators. If your refrigerator malfunctions, you could have overlapping coverage from both warranties, which might lead to confusion about which warranty to use for repairs or replacements.

Identifying these types of duplicate coverage is vital for homeowners to make informed decisions about how to proceed when repairs or replacements are needed. Recognizing overlapping areas allows homeowners to navigate the claims process more efficiently and avoid unnecessary expenses.

Navigating Duplicate Coverage Effectively in Home Warranties

Dealing with duplicate coverage in home warranties requires a strategic approach to avoid confusion, streamline claims processing, and make the most of your protection plans. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to navigate duplicate coverage effectively:

1. Review Existing Policies:

Begin by thoroughly reviewing both your homeowner's insurance policy and your home warranty contract. Understand the coverage provided by each and make a list of items, systems, and appliances that are covered by both policies. This will help you identify areas of potential duplicate coverage.

2. Understand Contract Terms:

Familiarize yourself with the terms and conditions of both your homeowner's insurance and home warranty contracts. Pay close attention to covered items, exclusions, limitations, and claim procedures. This will help you pinpoint where overlaps may occur and where each policy's coverage begins and ends.

3. Identify Overlapping Coverage:

Compare the list of covered items from both policies. Highlight instances where the same item or aspect of your home is covered by both your homeowner's insurance and your home warranty. This step will enable you to clearly see where duplicate coverage exists.

4. Evaluate Coverage Benefits:

Examine the benefits offered by each policy for the overlapping items. Determine which policy provides better terms, higher coverage limits, or more favorable claim processes. This evaluation will help you decide which policy to utilize in case of a repair or replacement.

5. Contact Your Providers:

Reach out to both your homeowner's insurance provider and your home warranty company. Discuss the overlapping coverage with them and inquire about their recommendations for handling situations with duplicate coverage. They can provide insights on how to proceed and which policy to prioritize for specific scenarios.

6. Customize Your Coverage:

If your home warranty allows for customization, consider adjusting your coverage to eliminate redundancy. For instance, you might adjust your home warranty to exclude items that are already covered by your homeowner's insurance. This can help you optimize your protection while minimizing the risk of duplicate coverage.

7. Keep Communication Clear:

If you need to file a claim, ensure that your communication with your insurance providers is clear and accurate. Clearly state your policy for the claim and provide all necessary documentation. This will help avoid confusion and expedite the claims process.

8. Update Coverage Regularly:

Periodically review your insurance policies and home warranty contracts to ensure they align with your current needs. As you make changes or updates to your coverage, keep an eye out for potential duplicate coverage situations that may arise over time.

9. Seek Professional Guidance:

If you're uncertain about how to handle duplicate coverage, consider seeking guidance from insurance professionals. They can provide expert advice tailored to your specific situation and help you make informed decisions.

10. Keep Records:

Maintain a record of your communications with insurance providers, including emails, phone conversations, and claim-related documents. A well-organized record can be invaluable in any disputes or confusion.

By following these steps, you can navigate duplicate coverage effectively, make informed choices, and ensure that you get the most value from your home warranties and insurance policies without paying twice for the same coverage. Ultimately, the goal is to optimize your protection, streamline claims processes, and minimize unnecessary expenses.


Understanding duplicate coverage in home warranties is crucial for homeowners seeking to optimize their protection while managing expenses efficiently. By recognizing potential areas of overlap, comparing coverage terms, and customizing policies, homeowners can make informed decisions that lead to cost savings and enhanced peace of mind. The key is to be proactive in reviewing policies and seeking professional advice when needed, ensuring that your investments in home warranties provide the maximum value and protection you deserve. If you need help, use our website for a free quote, or call (866)-432-1283.

Protect What's Most Important With
America's #1 Home Warranty

Get A Free Quote
  • Comprehensive Plans
  • Highly Competitive Rates
  • 24/7/365 Claims
  • Online Portal

Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958