Top 10 Real Estate Agents And Realtors In Milwaukee

Ellie Brooks

Written By Ellie Brooks

Published 01/23/24
Top 10 Real Estate Agents And Realtors In Milwaukee

Welcome to Brew City, home to the happiest cheeseheads around! Whether you're a Cream City lover, a Lake Michigander, or just someone craving a tasty bratwurst, there's no place quite like Milwaukee. And when it comes to finding the perfect real estate agent to help you navigate this vibrant city, we've got you covered. 

From the shores of Lake Michigan to the historic architecture of the Third Ward, we've scoured the city to bring you our list of the top 10 realtors in Milwaukee. These superhuman agents are the cream of the crop, the crème de la crème of the real estate world, and they'll stop at nothing to find you the home of your dreams. So grab a cold Miller, sit back, and get ready to discover the power players who can turn your Milwaukee housing fantasies into reality. Let's dive into the world of Brew City's best real estate agents!

Navigating Milwaukee's Real Estate Landscape

Before we delve into the profiles of the top real estate agents in Milwaukee, let's take a moment to understand the unique dynamics of the local real estate market. Milwaukee, situated on the western shore of Lake Michigan, boasts a diverse range of neighborhoods, each with its own charm and character. From the historic Third Ward to the family-friendly suburbs, the city offers a variety of housing options.

Key Considerations for Milwaukee Real Estate

When it comes to real estate in Milwaukee, certain factors play a pivotal role in shaping the market. Proximity to Lake Michigan, neighborhood safety, school districts, and access to amenities are some of the crucial elements that potential homebuyers should consider. A competent real estate agent should be well-versed in these factors and guide clients accordingly.

How to Choose the Best Real Estate Agent in Milwaukee

The process of selecting the right real estate agent can be overwhelming, given the plethora of options available. To ensure a successful real estate transaction in Milwaukee, consider the following criteria when choosing an agent:

A. Local Expertise Matters

Milwaukee's real estate market is diverse, with nuances that only a local expert can navigate effectively. Look for an agent who has a deep understanding of the various neighborhoods, market trends, and property values in the city. A well-informed agent can provide valuable insights and help you make informed decisions.

B. Client Reviews and Testimonials

Before committing to an agent, take the time to read reviews and testimonials from their past clients. Online platforms, social media, and real estate websites often feature feedback from individuals who have worked with the agent. Positive reviews can be a strong indicator of an agent's professionalism, reliability, and commitment to client satisfaction.

C. Communication Skills

Effective communication is the cornerstone of a successful real estate partnership. Choose an agent who is responsive, transparent, and proactive in keeping you informed throughout the buying or selling process. A good communicator can help alleviate stress and ensure a seamless experience.

D. Negotiation Skills

Real estate transactions involve negotiations, and having an agent with strong negotiation skills can be a game-changer. Whether you're buying or selling, your agent should be adept at securing the best possible deal on your behalf.

Top 10 Real Estate Agents And Realtors In Milwaukee


Kristel Sikora


Meet Kristel Sikora, the dynamic force behind your real estate dreams at Shorewest Realtors - New Berlin. With an unwavering commitment to your satisfaction, Kristel brings a wealth of expertise in sales, marketing, negotiation, and contract management. Her extensive experience and sharp analytical skills make her the go-to expert for all your home-buying and selling needs.

Kristel's outstanding track record speaks for itself, consistently ranking as the top sales agent in units and volume at the Shorewest New Berlin Office three years in a row. As an esteemed member of the Shorewest President's Club for six consecutive years, her dedication to excellence is undeniable. She has achieved over $80 million in career sales, with an impressive 300 closings and counting.

Recognized as one of America's Best Real Estate Professionals, Kristel is ranked in the top 1.5% nationally among her peers. Her remarkable accomplishments have earned her the esteemed National Sales Award multiple times. These accolades reflect her unmatched commitment to providing exceptional service and results.

Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or a seasoned investor, Kristel Sikora's client-focused approach and industry expertise make her the perfect ally in your real estate journey. With Kristel by your side, expect nothing less than excellence, efficiency, and an unwavering dedication to your overall satisfaction.

Website | Website

Joanne Schaefer-Roberson


Joanne Schaefer-Roberson is a seasoned real estate professional at Shorewest Realtors - New Berlin, equipped with an impressive track record of success. With countless properties sold and millions in sales production volume, she possesses the knowledge and experience to meet all of your real estate needs. As an Associate Vice President and esteemed member of the Shorewest Realtors President's Club, Joanne consistently goes above and beyond to deliver exceptional results.

Joanne's commitment to excellence is evident through her accolades, receiving the yearly National Sales Award and consistently achieving Multi-Million Dollar Producer status. She holds numerous certifications, including Certified Home Marketing Specialist (CHMS),Certified Re-Marketing Specialist (CRMS),Certified Shorewest Relocation Specialist (CSRS),Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR),and Short Sale and Foreclosure Resource (SFR). Her dedication to ongoing education is exemplified by graduating from prestigious real estate training programs such as the Floyd Wickman Real Estate Training and Chris Leader's Edge Real Estate Training.

Not only is Joanne highly regarded within the industry, but she has also been recognized by the Milwaukee Journal/Sentinel as Realtor of the Week and invited as a roundtable presenter at the All Company Sales Conference. Her exceptional expertise has earned her a ranking in the top 1% of all Metro MLS agents.

When working with Joanne Schaefer-Roberson, you can trust that you will receive unparalleled professionalism, extensive market knowledge, and unwavering dedication. With her by your side, you can confidently navigate the real estate landscape and achieve your goals.

Website | Website

Laurie Reichelt


Laurie Reichelt is a seasoned real estate professional with a career spanning over a decade, Laurie is the trusted choice for all your real estate needs. Committed to delivering exceptional service, she will guide you every step of the way, whether you're buying or selling your home.

Leveraging First Weber's comprehensive suite of marketing tools and their extensive national and global network, Laurie ensures that you're making the right choice when selecting an agent. Her impressive track record speaks for itself, with over $100 million in career sales and a reputation as a top-producing agent.

Recognized as a 5-star agent, Laurie consistently receives the highest ratings for client satisfaction. Her competitive market knowledge and impeccable negotiation skills set her apart, making her a go-to specialist for fine homes, relocations, and properties near lakes.

When partnering with Laurie Reichelt, expect nothing less than dedicated and knowledgeable support throughout your real estate journey. Rest assured, she will be your unwavering resource, ensuring all your questions and concerns are addressed. Trust Laurie to make your real estate experience smooth, successful, and satisfying.

Website | Website

Renee Koepsel


Renee Koepsel is the unrivaled expert in selling homes in the Mukwonago School District, holding the prestigious title of No. 1 Home Seller for an astounding 17 consecutive years, from 2005 to 2022. With an impressive 18 years of proven results, Renee's track record speaks for itself.

As an Associate Vice President, Broker Associate, and esteemed member of the President's Club for 18 years, Renee consistently delivers exceptional outcomes. She has been recognized as a Million Dollar Club Member for 19 years and has received the National Sales Award for 18 years. Renee's volume of sales in the Mukwonago School District has consistently ranked at the pinnacle for 18 years.

Leading the pack as the Sales and Listing Leader in the Shorewest-Mukwonago Office from 2005 to 2021, Renee has achieved over $216 million in career sales. Her exceptional talent and dedication were evident from the start, being honored as the Rookie of the Year for Listings in 2004.

Renowned for her commitment to client satisfaction, Renee has received the FIVE STAR Best in Client Satisfaction Real Estate Agent award for an impressive 15 years, as recognized by Milwaukee Magazine.

As a professional Realtor, Renee Koepsel is dedicated, focused, and hardworking. She is a full-time Broker Associate who is committed to providing the highest quality of real estate services to sellers and buyers alike. When you choose Renee as your trusted agent, you can expect unmatched expertise, unwavering dedication, and exceptional results.

Website | Website

Wendy Kaprelian


Wendy Kaprelian, a proud Wisconsin native, has been making waves in the real estate industry since 2007. As a full-time realtor and resident of Franklin, WI, Wendy brings her passion and dedication to every transaction. With a background as a former flight attendant for Milwaukee's beloved Midwest Airlines, Wendy knows the value of exceptional customer service.

In her free time, Wendy indulges in her love for travel, golf, and quality time with her family. Committed to her community, she actively engages in local initiatives and is a member of St. Mesrob Armenian Church.

As a specialist in residential, condominium, and investment properties, Wendy is well-versed in navigating the intricacies of real estate transactions. Her consistent performance as a multi-million dollar producer has earned her a coveted membership in the Shorewest Realtors President's Club.

Wendy's expertise extends beyond the local market, as she holds the designation of a Certified Shorewest Relocation Specialist (CSRS). Her success has even taken her to the small screen, with an appearance on HGTV's House Hunters.

For a personalized and dedicated real estate experience, trust Wendy Kaprelian to guide you through your home buying or selling journey. With her unwavering commitment to her clients and vast expertise, Wendy ensures your real estate goals are met with utmost professionalism and care. Connect with her on Facebook to stay up-to-date with her latest ventures.

Website | Website

Brian E Roslawski


Meet Brian E Roslawski, a highly experienced Realtor with a deep understanding of the Milwaukee County area, including Waukesha, Brookfield, Whitefish Bay, Shorewood, and Mequon. Whether you're buying or selling, Brian is dedicated to serving your real estate needs and ensuring a pleasant and successful experience.

With extensive knowledge of the local communities, Brian's strong negotiation skills and commitment to excellent service set him apart as a top-notch Realtor. As a seller, Brian will work tirelessly to sell your property quickly and at the highest possible price, offering a free home valuation to get you started.

If you're a buyer, Brian will guide you through the process of finding your ideal home. Access to comprehensive search tools and personalized assistance with the home showing process ensures that you find the perfect fit. Brian's expertise in negotiation guarantees that you get the best deal possible with every real estate transaction.

Above all, Brian finds true satisfaction in seeing the smiles that accompany a successful real estate transaction. When you choose Brian E Roslawski as your Realtor, you can expect dedicated service, expert knowledge, and a commitment to your satisfaction. Start your real estate journey with Brian today and experience the difference a trusted Realtor can make.

Website | Website

Paula J. Bailey

Paula J. Bailey is a dedicated full-time professional Associate at Shorewest Realtors, with outstanding credentials and a deep commitment to serving her clients. As a licensed Real Estate Broker since 2005 and Assistant Sales Director, Paula brings a wealth of expertise to every transaction. Her exceptional service has been recognized for 13 consecutive years, earning her the prestigious 5 Star Best in Client Satisfaction award from 2011 to 2023.

Paula's excellence extends beyond client satisfaction, as she was named Real Trends America's Best Real Estate Professional in 2017. With a continuous drive for learning and growth, Paula graduated from the Ninja Selling Mastery Program in 2018.

As a valuable member of the Shorewest Realtors President's Club and a recipient of the Yearly National Sales Award, Paula consistently achieves multi-million dollar sales. She holds several certifications, including Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR),Certified Home Marketing Specialist (CHMS),Certified Shorewest Relocation Specialist (CSRS),and Certified Real Estate Negotiator (CREN). Paula is an active member of the National Association of Realtors (NAR),Wisconsin Realtors Association (WRA),and Greater Milwaukee Association of Realtors (GMAR).

Paula's dedication to serving her clients' needs can be traced back to 2000, and she is well-equipped to assist you locally, nationally, and internationally. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or in need of Buyer Agency protection, Paula provides comprehensive services tailored to your unique needs. Count on her expertise, guidance, and commitment to ensure a smooth and informed real estate experience.

Website | Website

Kelly Seaman


Kelly Seaman is an accomplished sales executive and top producer at First Weber Realtors, Berkshire Hathaway's affiliate, located in the North Shore office. With over 23 years of experience in the real estate industry, Kelly has established herself as a leader and consistently ranks among the top 10 agents in all company sales and metro Milwaukee agents. She holds certifications in Accredited Buyer Representation and Luxury Home Marketing.

Recognized as an office leader, mentor, and adviser, Kelly actively participates in training sessions and focus groups, contributing to the growth and success of others. Her success as an entrepreneur stems from her ability to run a business effectively. Prior to her real estate career, Kelly spent 12 years at Accenture as a senior manager, working across the country in areas such as information technology, marketing, and finance.

Kelly is a graduate of the University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee, holding a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration and Information Technology. She is deeply involved in charitable work, particularly in supporting the needs of women and girls. With 35 years of marriage and two children and grandchildren, Kelly enjoys cooking, boating, practicing yoga, and indulging in good wine. She also cherishes spending time with loved ones and traveling.

When working with Kelly Seaman, you can expect a dedicated professional who delivers exceptional results. Her extensive experience, leadership, and commitment to giving back to the community make her an invaluable asset in achieving your real estate goals.

Website | Website

Sarah Oberbrunner


Sarah Oberbrunner is a highly experienced real estate agent with over 20 years of industry knowledge. She understands that educating her customers and providing unwavering support throughout the buying and selling processes are essential in helping them achieve their goals. Sarah takes pride in building relationships based on trust and confidence, resulting in over 95% of her business coming from repeat clients and referrals.

With a keen attention to detail, Sarah equips her clients with all the necessary tools and provides expert guidance to ensure a successful transaction. Her exceptional negotiation skills have placed her in the top 1% of Realtors in Southeastern Wisconsin. Despite this distinction, Sarah treats each relationship as unique and individually important, never compromising on personalized service.

When working with Sarah Oberbrunner, you can expect a dedicated advocate who values your specific needs and preferences. Her commitment to delivering exceptional results and her ability to foster meaningful connections sets her apart in the real estate industry. Trust Sarah to navigate the complexities of your real estate journey with professionalism, integrity, and a focus on your success.

Website | Website

Ed Pestka


Meet Ed Pestka, a highly experienced real estate agent serving southeastern Wisconsin with a strong connection to Racine. With over 14 years of real estate expertise, Ed is equipped to guide you through the next steps in your life, whether it be finding your dream home or downsizing and selling your current property.

As an Accredited Buyer's Representative, Senior Real Estate Specialist, and Certified Residential Specialist, Ed possesses the knowledge to cater to your specific needs. With him as your agent, rest assured that he will address any issues that arise, allowing you to focus on other aspects of your life.

Leading the Ed Pestka Team at Shorewest Realtors, Ed works alongside his dedicated team to provide comprehensive support throughout your real estate journey. Their goal is to deliver positive results and ensure a smooth and successful experience for you.

Ed's impressive designations include Accredited Buyer's Representative (ABR),Certified Residential Specialist (CRS),Certified Shorewest Relocation Specialist (CSRS),and Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES). These designations further testify to Ed's commitment and ability to serve a diverse range of clients.

Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, a seasoned investor, or a senior looking to transition to a new phase of life, Ed Pestka and his team are here to assist you. Their unwavering dedication, expertise, and commitment to achieving positive results make them the ideal choice for all your real estate needs.

Website | Website

When to Hire a Real Estate Agent in Milwaukee

Timing is crucial in real estate, and knowing when to hire a professional can save you time and money. Consider the following scenarios:

A. Buying in a Competitive Market

In a seller's market, where demand exceeds supply, having a real estate agent can give you a competitive edge. They can help you navigate multiple offers, negotiate effectively, and secure the home of your dreams.

B. Selling for Maximum Value

When selling a property, an experienced agent can help you showcase your home in the best light, set an optimal listing price, and negotiate with potential buyers to maximize your return on investment.

C. Navigating Legalities and Paperwork

Real estate transactions involve complex legalities and paperwork. Hiring an agent ensures that you comply with all regulations, contracts are accurately drafted, and the transaction progresses smoothly.

Wrapping Up

Navigating Milwaukee's real estate market requires a strategic approach and the guidance of a knowledgeable professional. Whether you're buying or selling, choosing the right real estate agent is paramount to your success. The top 10 agents highlighted in this guide are just a starting point – explore their profiles, read client testimonials, and consider your specific needs to make an informed decision.

In closing, Milwaukee's real estate market offers exciting opportunities for both buyers and sellers. By understanding the local dynamics, choosing a top-tier agent, and staying informed about market trends, you can embark on your real estate journey with confidence and success.

Support Your Clients With a Real Estate Home Warranty

As a real estate agent in Memphis, managing properties can be a daunting task, especially when unexpected breakdowns occur. This is where Liberty Home Guard comes in. We understand the challenges that realtors face in maintaining, repairing, and replacing appliances and systems in the properties they represent. That's why we've partnered with quality realtors across the United States, including Milwaukee, to offer solutions that help protect your clients' investments.

Partnering with Liberty Home Guard means working with a company that is committed to providing quality service and support to real estate professionals. We understand the importance of protecting your clients' investments, and our partnership program is designed to help you do just that.

At Liberty Home Guard, we are committed to helping real estate agents in Milwaukee and beyond protect their clients' properties. To learn more about our Realtor Partnership Program and how we can help you, visit our website or call us at (866)-558-8712. Our team is always ready to answer any questions you may have and provide you with the support you need to succeed in the real estate industry.

Get Started With
Liberty Home Guard

Check out our top rated plans and policies.

Liberty Home Guard
Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958
Liberty Home Guard
Special Offer
Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958