Choosing the Best Home Warranty
Liberty Home Guard

Expert-Reviewed Content: Guided by Editorial Standards

Rachel Cherem

Written By Rachel Cherem

Published 09/11/25
Home Warranty Plans

Choosing the Best Home Warranty: A Comprehensive Guide to Top Provider

Key Takeaways:

  • Customer reviews don’t lie – With 16,000+ Google reviews and a 4.7 rating, Liberty Home Guard is one of the highest-rated providers in the industry, far ahead of competitors like ARW (3.9), Select (3.8), and HWA (1.8).
  • Reputation reflects service quality – High ratings are tied to fast claims processing, responsive support, and clear communication. Lower-rated competitors often show recurring issues with delays and limited coverage.
  • Technology + network strength – Liberty Home Guard’s proprietary platforms and nationwide technician base allow for faster resolutions (claims handled within 48 hours),which translates into stronger customer satisfaction scores.
  • Best overall value – Recognition from Forbes as “Best Value Home Warranty” reinforces what reviews already show: Liberty Home Guard delivers reliable service, transparent pricing, and customizable coverage that homeowners trust.

Finding a top rated home warranty can feel overwhelming with so many providers promising peace of mind. Homeowners often wonder who has the best home warranty and how to separate strong coverage from flashy marketing. With dozens of providers competing nationwide, comparing home warranty companies ratings is one of the best ways to see how they perform in the real world.

Use this guide as a cheat sheet. It breaks down what makes a good plan and helps navigate how to choose the best home warranty for you. One theme from this guide is reviews don’t lie: Liberty Home Guard is among the top-rated home warranty companies in the country. Why? We’ll walk through the features, coverage, and service that matter most. Plus, we share real insights in a comparison of the best home warranty reviews available today across leading companies in the space. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to look for and why Liberty Home Guard consistently ranks among the leaders in a growing industry. 
 

Inside the Rise of Top-Rated Home Warranty Providers

The residential use of service contracts to maintain expensive home equipment dates to the early 1970s. The industry's recent growth has been significant, with an average increase in market size of 5.6% each year since 2017. More Americans are seeing the value in home warranty protection, and more companies are getting in on the action. Today, over 60 home warranty providers compete across the United States.

The surge in competition has fueled innovation among the industry's key players. Traditionally, a home warranty protected the expensive appliances and systems that are standard to most homes: refrigerators, dishwashers, cooking appliances, laundry appliances, and plumbing, electrical, and heating systems. But now more and more providers have expansive offerings, covering niche home equipment and even a variety of home maintenance services. 

Liberty Home Guard has taken the lead in supporting comprehensive warranty plans with additional coverage options. Our 42-and counting-policy add-ons guarantee a custom-fit policy.

Protect What's Most Important With
America's #1 Home Warranty

Get A Free Quote
  • Comprehensive Plans
  • Highly Competitive Rates
  • 24/7/365 Claims
  • Online Portal

The Best Home Warranty Companies: The Reviews Don't Lie

It's important to choose a home warranty company that has a record of exceptional service. Millions of homeowners have shared their home warranty experiences online. And while numerical ratings offer a good frame of reference, authentic customer reviews can help you get a handle on coverage limitations, hidden costs, service quality and response time, and other criteria that should inform your choice in provider.

How do the home warranty industry's heavy hitters compare? Across multiple review platforms, Liberty Home Guard consistently ranks atop the competition. Let’s dive in…

Home Warranty Company Ratings on Google (2025)

Home Warranty Company Ratings on Google

Source: Google 

Home Warranty Company Ratings on Trustpilot (2025)

Home Warranty Company Ratings on Trustpilot

Source: Trustpilot

Home Warranty Company Ratings on BBB (2025)

Home Warranty Company Ratings on BBB

Source: BBB

Home Warranty Company Ratings on US News & World Report (2025)

Home Warranty Company Ratings on US News & World Report

Source: US News

How Technology Sets the Best Home Warranty Companies Apart

Faster Claims and Better Communication

One way to identify a good home warranty company is by looking at how they use technology to improve the customer experience. When a major system or appliance breaks down, time is critical. The top rated home warranty providers invest in tools that make submitting claims, scheduling service, and tracking progress seamless for homeowners. Fast response times and clear communication aren’t just nice to have—they are often what separates the best companies from the rest.

Tools That Keep Homeowners in Control

Today’s leading providers are using technology to give homeowners, technicians, and even real estate partners an edge. Platforms that centralize claims, service requests, and scheduling help reduce delays and ensure customers get back to normal quickly.

Liberty Home Guard’s Technology Advantage

Liberty Home Guard stands out in this area. Our proprietary tech stack includes dedicated portals for customers, technicians, and realtors, all designed for ease of use. We also leverage machine learning to optimize communication, streamline scheduling, and lower overall service costs. This commitment to innovation is one reason Liberty Home Guard consistently ranks at the top in home warranty companies ratings and earns some of the best home warranty reviews nationwide.

The Value of Swift Service

Provider response times are sometimes overlooked by homeowners as they shop for home warranty coverage, but the importance of speedy service is hard to overstate. The very purpose of home warranty coverage is to protect expensive equipment we can't do without. Malfunctioning kitchen appliances can prevent you from making meals at home. Faulty heating systems lead to discomfort-at best-during cold spells. When something breaks down, you need it fixed. And fast.

Less efficient warranty providers can take several days or even weeks to adequately resolve a customer claim. Liberty Home Guard has prioritized the elimination of service inefficiencies since our inception. Our robust nationwide network of home professionals and technicians ensures that there is always someone in your immediate proximity who is qualified to diagnose and resolve the problem with your home appliance or system. We're also one of the few companies that maintains a 24/7 customer support team. And our technological investments make scheduling and communication a breeze. 

Together, these assets enable us to set the high industry bar for response times. We respond to customer claims with 48 hours of receipt. And for our partners, swift service translates to swift payment. If you're in our technician network, you can effortlessly submit your invoice via the technician portal to be promptly paid.

Maintaining Your Home on the Go

We've all got busy lives. Whether you're a hardworking homeowner, technician with a full schedule of service calls, or realtor handling a multi-property portfolio, you need to be able to manage your warranty claims when you're away from your desk. Not every warranty provider can offer that option. Liberty Home Guard can.

Our customer, technician, and realtor portals are fully integrated within our mobile platform. You can submit or follow up on a claim, schedule service, upload an invoice or payment, and much more with nothing but your smartphone. It makes the overall home warranty experience that much simpler.

Why Liberty Home Guard Delivers the Best Value in Home Warranties

Choosing a home warranty is one of the smartest ways to reduce the financial risk of homeownership, but not all providers deliver the same level of service, coverage, or value. The key is finding a plan that is reliable and affordable with excellent customer support.

Liberty Home Guard consistently ranks among the top rated home warranty providers because we focus on fast claims processing, comprehensive coverage options, and transparent pricing. In fact, Forbes named Liberty Home Guard the best value home warranty company in America thanks to our combination of competitive pricing, customizable plans, and industry-leading customer satisfaction.

If you’re asking who has the best home warranty or comparing home warranty companies ratings, Liberty Home Guard is a proven choice trusted by homeowners nationwide.

Compare Liberty Home Guard Plans →

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How do I choose a home warranty company?

    To choose a home warranty company, review their coverage options to ensure they meet your needs and compare pricing, including service fees. Check customer reviews and ratings to gauge reliability, and confirm they work with licensed technicians in your area. Look for a straightforward claims process and clear contract terms

  • How much does a home warranty cost in 2025?

    In 2025, home warranty costs typically range from $300 to $800 per year, depending on the coverage plan and add-ons. The total cost varies based on the size of your home, the systems and appliances covered, and the provider you choose. You can see Liberty Home Guard plans here.

  • Do I need a home warranty if I have homeowners insurance?

    Home warranty and homeowners insurance serve different purposes. Homeowners insurance covers damage from events like fires or storms, while a home warranty covers repairs or replacements for systems and appliances that break down due to normal wear and tear. If you want extra protection for items like your HVAC, plumbing, or kitchen appliances, a home warranty is a valuable complement to homeowners insurance.

Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958(866) 225-7958
Liberty Home Guard
Special Offer
GET QUOTE
Liberty Home Guard
Need help?

Talk to our Liberty Home Guard Agents 24/7.

(866) 225-7958